Ordered these on a whim. Had the munchies in the middle of the night and started craving the lemon gs cookies with the icing on the bottom. These are absolutely NOT a *replacement* for them, but could anything be? I think not.However, these are quite a decent alternative. Nice cookie to icing ratio. I think if these were the regular sized oreos i might not care for them so much. I'm pretty picky with sweets and junk foods though. I hate to consume something thats already not good for me as it is, if i dont LOVE it lol so i typically end up eating one particular sweet almost exclusively.These are pretty good though and a nice change from the chocolate/hazelnut sweet i always go for.I'll probably continue to get these once in awhile to have around when i want something different than the usual. They're sweet and lemony, theyre delicate yet still a little indulgent. If you're thinking about trying them, go for it.